The Bat, in detail
The Bat is the first Harry Hole novel, published in Norwegian in 1997 and set almost entirely in Sydney, Australia. Norwegian detective Harry Hole has been sent across the world on a delicate assignment: a Norwegian woman has been murdered and Oslo wants a quiet observer on the ground, not an official investigator. Harry is warned to stay out of Australian police business. He immediately gets into it anyway.
What makes The Bat more than a routine procedural is its setting and the character Harry encounters there. His guide into Sydney's criminal underbelly is Andrew Kensington, an Aboriginal man working for the New South Wales police, who takes Harry through the city's bars and margins and tells him stories — Dreamtime stories, histories of displacement, the weight of being a man between two worlds. The murdered Norwegian woman turns out not to be the only victim, and the pattern that emerges is one of predation against women who have drifted far from home.
Nesbø's Harry Hole is already recognizable here: the drinking, the recklessness, the habit of forming attachments he has no business forming, the stubborn refusal to leave a case when he should. But this is a younger, less ossified Harry — one still capable of surprise, not yet calcified by all the cases that follow. The book's portrait of Sydney's Aboriginal communities, written by a Norwegian who spent time in Australia, holds up better than you might expect; it's clearly researched with care, though some readers will find the outsider perspective limiting.
The Bat is the shortest and most atmospheric entry in the Harry Hole series. Readers coming from the later, denser books may find it light. Readers coming in fresh will find a clean, propulsive thriller with an unexpectedly melancholy undertow. It is not the best Harry Hole novel — that argument belongs to The Snowman or The Leopard — but as an origin story it earns its place.
The big ideas
- 1.
Harry Hole's core contradictions — brilliant detective, chaotic person — are fully formed from the first chapter. The series doesn't build him so much as erode him.
- 2.
The novel uses Sydney's Aboriginal community not as backdrop but as thematic counterweight: Harry is also a displaced person, just with more power over his displacement.
- 3.
Violence against women is the book's actual subject, and Nesbø doesn't soften how systematic and mundane it is.