What it argues
Two sisters, dispossessed by the legal mechanics of entail after their father's death, move to a smaller house in Devonshire with reduced means and reduced prospects. Elinor is twenty-one, controlled, and perceptive; Marianne is seventeen, romantic, and openly contemptuous of emotional restraint. The novel is about what happens when each sister's dominant quality is tested by experience. Elinor discovers that composure is not the same as feeling nothing. Marianne discovers that romantic intensity is not the same as wisdom.
Austen's title is a trap. The older critical reading casts Elinor as the novel's moral ideal — all sense — and Marianne as cautionary excess — all sensibility. But the novel is less schematic than that. Elinor suffers. She suppresses genuine grief while performing social equanimity, and Austen doesn't reward her with numbness — she is in pain throughout. Marianne is not simply punished for feeling deeply; she is punished for attaching her feelings to a man who doesn't deserve them and for refusing to look at evidence. The real target is Willoughby, and the real argument is about what women are left with when the men who seem to understand them turn out to be operating on different rules.
What it gets right
- 1.
Emotional restraint is not the same as emotional absence. Elinor is one of literature's great sufferers in silence, and Austen doesn't let you mistake control for indifference.
- 2.
Marianne's problem is not that she feels too much but that she refuses to audit her feelings — to check whether the object is worthy of them.
- 3.
The entail system, which stripped daughters of inheritance in favor of male heirs, is not background detail. It is the central fact that puts every female character in a condition of precarity.
What it covers
Who wrote it
Jane Austen (1775–1817) was an English novelist whose six completed novels established ironic social realism as a major literary mode. Sense and Sensibility, her debut novel, was published in 1811 under the attribution "A Lady." Her later works — Pride and Prejudice, Mansfield Park, Emma, Northanger Abbey, and Persuasion — confirmed her as one of the most significant writers in the English language. She died at forty-one.