The Midnight Library by Matt Haig
The Midnight Library by Matt Haig

Contemporary fiction · 2020

The Midnight Library review

by Matt Haig

Open in Superbook

The verdict

Nora Seed is thirty-five and done.

Best for curious readers in the genre. Reading time: 5h 20m.

The Midnight Library by Matt Haig
The Midnight Library by Matt Haig

Talk to The Midnight Library like its author wrote you back.

Get the ideas that fit your life — not generic summaries.

  • Chat with the book
  • Audiobook-style main ideas
  • Adapts to your life and goals
  • Helps you take action
Open in Superbook

What it argues

Nora Seed is thirty-five and done. She has lost her job, her cat, her best friend through her own choices, and she no longer sees a reason to continue. On the night she decides to end her life, she finds herself in a vast library between life and death, staffed by Mrs. Elm — her childhood librarian — and stocked with infinite books representing the infinite lives Nora could have lived had she made different choices. She can enter any of them. The question is whether any life she could have lived is worth wanting.

Matt Haig is writing about depression in the architecture of a high-concept philosophical fable. The Midnight Library allows him to explore the texture of regret — what it actually is, as opposed to what we imagine it to be — by making the thought experiment literal. Nora enters the lives she gave up: the Olympic swimmer, the glaciologist, the rock star's wife, the woman who married the man she jilted. Each life is real and complete and has its own griefs. The novel's argument, delivered through accumulation rather than lecture, is that the regrets we use to condemn our lives are usually not what we imagine they would have resolved.

What it gets right

  1. 1.

    The novel's central argument is that regret is almost always a misreading of causation: the life you imagine you would have had if you'd made a different choice is not the life you would have actually had.

  2. 2.

    Depression is depicted here not as sadness but as a failure of the imagination — the inability to conceive of a future worth wanting or a present worth inhabiting.

  3. 3.

    Each parallel life Nora inhabits is fully real and has its own losses. The fantasy of the other life is always better than the reality of it.

What it covers

Who wrote it

Matt Haig is a British author of both fiction and non-fiction whose work is largely organized around mental health, depression, and the question of how to live. His memoir Reasons to Stay Alive (2015), about his own experience with depression and anxiety, introduced him to a broad readership outside literary fiction. The Midnight Library, published in 2020, was his breakout novel for a general audience, spending over a year on bestseller lists worldwide. Haig is also the author of the Humans series, Father Christmas Needs a Holiday, and How to Stop Time.

Chat with The Midnight Library

Ask questions. Adapt it to your life. Get answers based on your goals.

Download on the App Store