What it argues
The Priory of the Orange Tree is an epic standalone fantasy novel set across multiple continents with distinct cultures, political systems, and relationships to dragons. The story follows four main characters: Ead, a secret member of the Priory of the Orange Tree (a sisterhood that guards a sleeping fire-breathing evil), who has been embedded in the court of a queen she must protect without revealing her order; Tané, a woman in the Eastern lands training to be a dragonrider for a culture that reveres water dragons entirely differently than the West fears fire ones; Loth, the queen's exiled friend; and Niclays, a disgraced scholar. As an ancient evil stirs, the novel gradually brings these threads toward convergence.
The most interesting thing the book does is position two entirely different religious and mythological systems as both partially right and partially distorted by centuries of institutional interest. The Western kingdoms worship a saint who supposedly defeated a great evil; the Eastern cultures venerate dragons rather than fearing them; the Priory holds a third, older account. Shannon is writing about how history gets rewritten to serve power, and about how much damage gets done in the name of a story that turns out to be incomplete.
What it gets right
- 1.
The competing mythologies — Western saint-worship, Eastern dragon reverence, the Priory's older knowledge — are the novel's central argument. History is told by those with the power to tell it.
- 2.
Shannon constructs two fully realized civilizations with different relationships to the same creatures (dragons) and the same threat. The contrast does real thematic work.
- 3.
Ead's position as a spy in a court she's genuinely attached to gives the novel its most sustained tension — the conflict between institutional loyalty and personal love.
What it covers
Who wrote it
Samantha Shannon is a British author of fantasy fiction. She began publishing with The Bone Season, a dystopian fantasy series, while still a student at Oxford. The Priory of the Orange Tree (2019) is her first standalone novel and her most acclaimed work, praised for its meticulous world-building and its subversion of epic fantasy conventions. The book's release was notable for its length — nearly 850 pages as a standalone — and for its centering of queer relationships. Shannon continues to write the Roots of Chaos series, a companion to The Priory of the Orange Tree.