What it argues
Mexican Gothic is set in 1950s Mexico, where Noemí Taboada — fashionable, sharp, and underestimated — travels to a remote manor in the Mexican countryside after receiving a disturbing letter from her newly-married cousin Catalina. The letter describes visions, threats, and a creeping dread. What Noemí finds at High Place is the Doyle family: English mining colonizers who have settled in Hidalgo, grown wealthy on silver extraction, and built themselves a rotting mansion full of secrets. Something in the house — something biological and ancient — is feeding on the women inside it.
Moreno-Garcia is interested in what gothic horror looks like when you filter it through Mexican history and the indigenous-colonialist relationship. The Doyles aren't just creepy aristocrats; they're eugenicists who have been conducting experiments in racial "improvement" using the indigenous population as raw material. The horror of the house is not supernatural in an arbitrary sense — it grows directly from the colonial project. The rot and the mold and the violence are what extraction and domination produce. This is what makes the book more than a competent haunted-house novel.
What it gets right
- 1.
The novel's horror is rooted in colonialism and eugenics rather than random supernatural menace — the Doyle family's evil is the evil of extraction and racial domination made literal.
- 2.
Noemí Taboada is a deliberate rewrite of the passive Gothic heroine. Her refusal to be diminished is a structural choice, not just a character trait.
- 3.
The house itself is the novel's most original creation — its biology and the way it connects the people inside it is genuinely unsettling and not easy to shake.
What it covers
Who wrote it
Silvia Moreno-Garcia is a Mexican-Canadian author born in Sinaloa, Mexico, who writes across genres including science fiction, fantasy, horror, and historical fiction. Mexican Gothic, published in 2020, became a New York Times bestseller and was widely considered one of the best horror novels of its year. Her other novels include Gods of Jade and Shadow, Signal to Noise, and Velvet Was the Night. She lives in Vancouver, Canada, and is an editor and publisher as well as a novelist.