What it argues
Madeleine Hanna graduates from Brown University in 1982 and is in love with two very different men: Leonard Bankhead, brilliant and bipolar, and Mitchell Grammaticus, a religious studies major searching for something larger than himself. The Marriage Plot is a campus novel that keeps happening after graduation, tracking three young people across their early twenties as they discover that the romantic plots they've absorbed from novels don't quite fit the lives they're actually living. Madeleine's thesis is on the marriage plot in Victorian fiction — the convention by which novels end when the woman accepts or rejects a proposal — and Eugenides uses that frame consciously, asking what a marriage plot looks like when the person at its center has read enough to know she's inside one.
The novel has three roughly equal threads. Madeleine's story is the romantic center: her relationship with Leonard, which is genuinely passionate and genuinely devastating, traces what it looks like to love someone whose mental illness is also inseparable from the person you fell for. Leonard's chapters follow his bipolar disorder with clinical detail and without romanticizing it — the lithium, the hospitalizations, the version of Leonard who is flat and functional versus the version who is terrifying and alive. Mitchell's thread takes him across India on a spiritual search, working for Mother Teresa's mission in Calcutta, trying to figure out what meaning looks like outside the frameworks he was given.
What it gets right
- 1.
The marriage plot — the Victorian convention of courtship and resolution — survives in contemporary life not as a structure but as an expectation, and educated women in particular feel its pressure.
- 2.
Eugenides renders Leonard's bipolar disorder with rare precision: the manic Leonard and the lithium-flat Leonard are not metaphors but lived conditions, and loving one means accepting both.
- 3.
Madeleine's literary education is simultaneously her asset and her trap — she knows the plots she's in but cannot simply read her way out of them.
What it covers
Who wrote it
Jeffrey Eugenides is an American novelist born in Detroit in 1960. He is the author of three novels: The Virgin Suicides (1993), Middlesex (2002), which won the Pulitzer Prize for Fiction, and The Marriage Plot (2011), which was a finalist for the National Book Critics Circle Award. His work has been translated into more than thirty languages. He has taught creative writing at Princeton University and has been a fellow at the American Academy in Rome. He is known for extended periods between novels and for formal ambition that takes a different shape with each book.